Thomas jnr added: “Until you are able to come forward and address that, the story lives on. I mean in the end he had consensual sex with [redacted]. And [redacted] worked for you. The rest is atmospherics.
“You have moved on! People don’t know that and can’t accept that unless you say as much.”
Virginia Giuffre publicly accused Mountbatten-Windsor of raping and abusing her on three separate occasions when she was 17.
Giuffre, who died in April this year, repeated the allegations in her posthumous memoir – claiming the first incident took place when she was allegedly trafficked to London in March 2001.
Mountbatten-Windsor has denied the allegations, and a civil claim brought in the US was settled out of court with no admission of guilt.
When contacted by The Telegraph on Wednesday, Thomas jnr said Epstein never told him Giuffre had sex with Mountbatten-Windsor, but said he was repeating what he had read.
Thomas jnr said: “He never told me that she had sex with Andrew. When I say that he had sex with her, consensual sex, that’s just what I had read in the press.”
Later emails in the exchange appear to show Epstein abandoning the subject and moving on to discuss currency.
On Tuesday, the former head of MI6 urged the relevant authorities to investigate Mountbatten-Windsor’s involvement with Epstein to its fullest extent.
Sir Alex Younger said MI6 had no involvement in monitoring Mountbatten-Windsor’s activities, as this had been the remit of its domestic counterpart MI5.
But reacting to an interview with survivors of Epstein’s crimes, broadcast on BBC Newsnight, Young, who served as the chief of the Secret Intelligence Service from 2014 to 2020, said: “That is utterly horrifying. It’s deeply affecting. I think we should pursue this until we have answers. Daylight is the best disinfectant.”
Asked by Victoria Derbyshire, the Newsnight presenter, on Tuesday whether MI5 would have been aware of “everybody Prince Andrew mixed with” as a trade envoy, Young said: “I don’t know. I was chief of MI6”, before adding that the matter had not crossed his desk.
Coming from one of the UK’s most senior intelligence officers, Young’s comments will add even more pressure on Mountbatten-Windsor to testify to the US Congress committee investigating the scandal.
The comments come at a time when the Epstein files may soon be published in full after a significant vote in Washington.
On Tuesday, the House of Representatives voted almost unanimously to compel the US Justice Department to publish more files. The legislation must now pass through the Senate before it can be signed into law by Donald Trump.
Representatives of Mountbatten-Windsor have been contacted for comment.
Sign up to Herald Premium Editor’s Picks, delivered straight to your inbox every Friday. Editor-in-Chief Murray Kirkness picks the week’s best features, interviews and investigations. Sign up for Herald Premium here.
